The Druid's Garden

Spiritual Journeys in Tending the Land, Permaculture, Wildcrafting, and Regenerative Living

Shifting Beyond Corporate Exploitation: Meaningful Work and Reconnecting with Ourselves and the Land May 2, 2014

I’ll start by saying that I wasn’t sure I was ever going to post this blog post.  I started working on it over six months ago, and debated posting because it deviated from my usual posts about homesteading, simple living, druidry, and so forth. But as I read and reread this post, I realized that what I had written had everything to do with those things, and are important issues to discuss in regards to sustainable living and spiritual practices–or rather, the things that prevent us from doing such.  So, here it is, in its entirety–the post I almost didn’t publish.

 

Meaningful, Productive work of the past!

Meaningful, Productive work of the past!

The Idea of Meaningful Work

It used to be that for the bulk of humanity, “work” meant daily interaction with the land and the home cottage industry (that is, the work of producing goods for home use, such as clothing, medicine, etc).  In agrarian societies, this work entailed being out every day in the fields and forests, tilling the soil, growing your crops, hunting wild game, harvesting wood for buildings and fencing, saving seeds, milking cows, brewing ale, tending your herds and livestock, cooking from your own pantries, stocking those pantries, rendering soap, doing laundry, and so forth.  Most of human labor was, in fact, wrapped up in food production (with traditional societies engaging in anywhere from 70-90% of the workforce in the production of food) and in providing for one’s own continued survival.  One’s work, then, was directly related to one’s relationship with the land.  If the land was well-tended, those on the land prospered.  Balance and long-term sustainability were the keys upon which survival rested.

 

With the rise of industrialization, people moved from the farms to the factories in the cities, which promised faster production and reduced the input of human labor (for example, the invention of the spinning machine in the UK). As Upton Sinclair describes in The Jungle, however,these positions weren’t always all that they were hoped to be or imagined.  Regardless of the conditions in the factories, the idea if meaningful work drastically shifted, and now, we are at the extreme opposite end of that spectrum.  What is meaningful work today?  How do we engage in it?

 

In this post, I’d like to use the framework of “meaningful work” I want to investigate the issues surrounding work, spirituality, and sustainability in this post today by examining the working lives of two of my friends. Both of my friends walk a druidic path and both were working under conditions that challenge their relationship with the natural world, their sense of well-being, and their ability to maintain a meaningful spiritual life. Over a period of time, they have both shared their experiences and stories with me.  Since writing, both have found different employment, so they are at no risk in my posting these stories. I don’t know how widespread or representative their experiences are on the broader scale, but I suspect that they are pretty widespread, and I want to highlight their experiences and talk about some of the potential consequences to spiritual life and sustainability.

 

Defining Meaningful Work

I’d like to posit a definition–meaningful work is work with meaning and substance, it allows one to be positively emotionally involved, feel fulfilled, and gain benefits beyond financial.  Meaningful work also allows enough time that spiritual pursuits, quality of life, and overall happiness also are embraced.  Meaningful work likely means different things to very different people–we all need to explore our own idea of what meaningful work is, and how we can best engage in it.  What I will say, however, is that a good portion of our society is not, unfortunately, able to engage in meaningful work at this time.

 

The Story of Sage: Exploitation of Persons

One person, who we will call “Sage,” works at a major fabric and craft retailer, one that has a presence in most major cities and small towns around the country. Her retailer has close to 30 employees. Almost all of the employees work between 35-39 hours a week (39 hours a week to keep them from getting benefits, including access to healthcare). The human consequences of the 39 hour workweek are real and severe: rising healthcare costs, no financial security for their future, and not being paid a livable wage puts them in a situation where they are living from paycheck to paycheck with no end in sight (and this is certainly a broader trend within retail workers in the USA).  In fact, despite working hard at her job, Sage is forced to get food stamps to help pay for her groceries. This 39-hour a week practice is very widespread and yet the human consequences of it are not discussed nor considered–rather, we have laws put in place to uphold these practices and maximize profits, rather than having paws put in place to protect workers. For Sage, who has a college education but cannot find work in her field, this means working multiple low-wage jobs in order to make ends meet.

 

The other thing about Sage’s job is her lack of autonomy or control over her schedule. Despite the fact that her retail business is open the same hours each week, have the same shipments and work to do each week, and know well the work that is to be done each week, nobody who works there–except for upper management–has a consistent schedule.  A week before she is to work, Sage gets a schedule–it varies from day to day, number of hours worked, and so forth.  If Sage wants to go out of town, she has to go beg to her manager for time off (months in advance) and be at the manager’s mercy as to whether or not she’ll get the time off (and won’t know till the week she is scheduled to work).  This makes planning trips, family events, doctor’s appointments, even a simple evening at the theater, an impossibility.  She will never know if the manager is in a good mood, and if the manager will grant her request. Likewise, on her days off she is frequently called into work and, if she says “no” too many times, she may not have a job at all. This means that at any given moment, Sage is at the beck and call of an employer who does not even respect her enough to offer her a livable wage nor healthcare or other benefits.  Why does this employer act like it owns Sage?  Does it, in fact, own her?

 

As a druid, Sage’s situation is further complicated because of her holidays.  For example, last year when she asked for Samhuinn off, she was asked “is that real?” and “I don’t think you are telling me the truth.” After providing some documentation that Sage’s holiday was real, the manager said “well if you are getting this ‘new year’ off, you are working all of new years here.” I suspect that many druids in America who are open about our spiritual path have had such uncomfortable conversations, and often are unable to get our basic holidays off.

 

And thus, Sage works. Sage works for a pittance of wages, enough for her to rent and eat, but not enough for anything else.  She dreams of opening her own business, an art studio or a farm, but with little savings because of her working conditions, this dream continues to be far off in the distance.  She wishes for these things to be able to engage in meaningful work, work that is fulfilling and allows her to be prosperous.

 

The Story of Rue: Money as Entrapment

Now we’ll turn to Rue, who, despite having a full-time job with benefits and a much more comfortable salary, suffers at the hands of rather tyrannical employers. He works for a major financial firm who collects debt in the USA; the firm itself has a reputation well known for being unethical and have broken multiple laws (they pay their fines, continue to be in business, and continue to break the law). Rue also describes  the mind games, berating, and other mental abuse that upper management inflicts upon the employees.

 

Rue, who works at a manager at this firm, is in the same entrapped state that Sage finds herself in. Rue works insane hours (often 80-100 per week, including being asked to work several 14-hour shift days in a row or being asked to come in at 7am after working 7am to 10pm the previous day). For this employer, the volume of calls, rather than the quality of work, is what matters, so bringing employees in for longer hours means more profits on their bottom line–again, not caring about the the quality of life for employees. The consequences of this on Rue’s spiritual and personal life are obvious–when he finally is able to drag himself home after a 14-hour work day, he has no energy left to do anything.  He has very little time to spend with himself, his family, or his friends. He has no time to sit under a tree and commune. He becomes, in his words, like a zombie, a half-person, whose soul is ensnared by the corporation and who lacks the most important of human qualities–freedom.

 

There is also the matter of how much the employees make and the circumstances under which they make it–another form of entrapment. Unlike Sage, who makes a pittance and can’t afford much, Rue’s firm uses an opposite and equally entrapping approach–making lots and lots of money and bribing employees to higher performance quotas with lots of glittery consumerist goods, like plasma TVs (Rue tells me has has several of them, unopened, in boxes in his living room). The commission system ensures that workers will do everything in their power to collect the debt rather than seek solutions for those they are calling; with each account they close, they gain bonuses. Rue describes to me the call he made to a single mother who cannot pay her student loans and the ethical challenge is faced with–between giving her a year of deferment or demanding part of her wages she needs to make ends meet. Since “all calls are recorded for quality assurance purposes” if he gives out too many deferments, not only will he be called into an upper-manager’s office and given a talking to, he risks the financial implications of not meeting his monthly quota.

 

The amount that that these employees take home is in itself entrapping. Most of the people who work at Rue’s company make way more money than they would in other lines of work–money becomes the carrot at the end of the stick. This is a job that can be done with good training but does not require college degrees–so its better money than most people could get doing anything else. Despite the negative nature of the work environment, the mental abuse that they suffer and that they are required to inflict on others, people continue to work there because the money is just too good. Once you start making money at that standard of living, it becomes harder to get out of it, harder to see beyond the glittery objects, plasma televisions, and high class apartments in the big city lifestyle. Its a lifestyle that sucks you in–materialism, consumerism, and the promise of more and more “stuff” to fill the empty void.  Is this work meaningful? Is it rewarding?  According to Rue–not in the slightest.

 

Broader Thoughts

In The Empire of Illusion, Chris Hedges discusses how corporations and CEOs now exhibit psychopathic behaviors (a discussion alive and well on the web here and here).  Psychopathic leadership in corporations is more common than ever. We see this at work in the stories of Rue and Sage–corporations who treat their employees more like automatons than people, don’t respect them enough to either pay them a living wage (in the case of Sage) or provide them with enough autonomy and consistency of schedule in order to do anything meaningful (in the case of both).  The mental abuse that both describe in their work environments is appalling, and leaves them drained and exhausted when not working.

 

It makes me wonder–how many people out there are working in these kinds of situations, working multiple jobs to make ends meet, being unable to engage in any kind of meaningful work? How many of them do this and have no time for anything else?  I look at my students, many of whom are in this same situation, trying to balance getting an education which is supposed to get them a better life (and lead to meaningful work), and working 2 or 3 different jobs to pay their tuition and living expenses. It is no wonder that television ends up being a big distraction–the mental energy required for TV (even when compared to reading) is much less.  Its a distraction, a way to wind down at the end of the day, a way to get wrapped up in the illusion of something else.  But when you are in this exhausted mindset, unable to make meaningful time for yourself, what else can you accomplish? You don’t have the time for deep spiritual insights, developing deep connections with each other or the land around you.  You don’t have three hours to sit under an ancient maple and hear its stories.  When we depend on the corporation for everything–livelihood, food, water, shelter, transportation, entertainment–we give up our power and autonomy.  We give up our freedom and inspiration.  It is, perhaps, the great tragedy of our age–what we exchange in order to live and survive in 21st century America.  The work is not meaningful, its not fulfilling, and its not really doing anything to better our world or our communities.

 

I think its important to point out that this phenomenon is no different than what we see corporations doing to animals and our lands.  Oil companies engage in unsafe practices that cause oil spills, chemical companies dump pollutants into our rivers and oceans, mountains are removed and ecosystems are destroyed for the sake of profits, natural gas companies inject the very land beneath our feet with toxic chemicals to extract fossil fuel, the list goes on and on.  Livestock, from angora rabbits to chickens to cows, also suffer a similar fate.  They are boxed in, fattened up, and treated as mere objects.  From this perspective, things seem very dire indeed…but are they?

 

Meaningful Work and Viable Alternatives

If engaging in meaningful work is a goal that can help us be more mindful of our world around us, give us time for creative expression, and allows us once again a closer relationship with nature, how do we find such work? Of course, one has to figure out how to pay one’s bills, one’s taxes, and put food on the table.  With land being so expensive, the old American dream of homesteading on the frontier really isn’t viable for many anymore.  And yet, shifts back in the direction are certainly taking place. With the steady rise in farmer’s markets (even year round ones, like we have here in Michigan), people have more opportunity than 10 or 20 years ago to grow/produce products that they love and make a living doing it.  Is local entrepreneurship the answer? Can entrepreneurial opportunities, farmer’s markets and the like allow people like Rue and Sage to reclaim the idea of meaningful work from yet another commodity that a corporation distributes to something that they organically create for themselves? I know lots of people who want to do this, and some that are taking that step and doing it–but its a scary place to step into.  What if the business fails? How will you pay the bills and make ends meet?

 

Farmer's market products

Farmer’s market products

I think about some of the farmers that I’ve met in the last few years at our local farmer’s markets. One couple who regularly come to our local market specialize in organic free range chickens and eggs.  They told me their story about how they were both investment bankers, making six figure salaries. They decided they’d had enough, left their jobs, and became organic farmers.  They are making maybe 20% of what they had made as bankers, but they were healthy, happy and living a life that they dreamed.  Another close friend used to teach, got fed up with the school system and politics, and now is a full-time organic farmer selling some of the most beautiful veggies and herbs I have ever seen. I think about several others I know, people in their mid to late 20’s, who decided that college educations were too expensive, and became landscape designers, drink specialists, mushroom growers, and more.  It seems that there ARE alternatives out there, but that they take the right kind of community and resources to begin.  And they take a very long time to become profitable enough to not need to do other kinds of work.

 

Is the public ready to support these kinds of endeavors on a larger scale–that is, pay the organic chicken farmer 3.50/lb per bird rather than 1.00/lb per bird if that bird is raised ethically and humanely?   I think the ultimate decision about whether these kinds of  shifts that people are taking towards more meaningful work succeed is how willing the broader community is in supporting such work.  With the rise in farmer’s markets and other alternatives, I think that people broadly are starting to “buy local” and recognize the importance of keeping their money in the local community.  And with these shifts, we all gain more opportunities to engage in meaningful work.

Advertisements
 

15 Responses to “Shifting Beyond Corporate Exploitation: Meaningful Work and Reconnecting with Ourselves and the Land”

  1. Karen Fisher Says:

    Thank you for this post. I think it’s an important topic that many people haven’t even started to think about. I had a retail job like’s Sage’s for less than a year, and I was treated similarly–no time off unless I asked for it, different hours every week, and they deliberately kept the department overstaffed so there wouldn’t be enough hours for all the employees. I was fortunate to have other job skills and a former employer willing to take me back–although that was also a draining, deadening job. At least it was full time. But just to play devil’s advocate, it’s not easy to make a living in the alternate economy. I have a few friends who were organic farmers but couldn’t make a living at it. They ended up with mainstream jobs again, although they’re in fields related to organic agriculture and alternative tech. People need to think carefully about what they’re willing to give up and different ways to create an income stream.

    • Willowcrow Says:

      Karen,
      I agree about it being incredibly difficult to make a living in an alternative economy–at least in our current situation. I think the more that consumers embrace local products and foods, and commit to buying them, and the more the laws are willing to protect small entrepreneurs, the better off everyone who is trying that path will be (I mention the law because the very progressive Michigan Right to Farm act was just destroyed yesterday…)

  2. Sara G Says:

    Adam Smith predicted the systematic abuse of workers to further the corporate bottom line way back in 1776. It’s frankly wired into the entire industrially-based economic system — a feature, not a bug — and it’s been there since the beginning. Workers for any business larger than a mom-and-pop, and for that matter workers for mom-and-pops run by unethical families, have always faced systematic psychological, emotional, physical, and economic abuse at the hands of their employers. What’s changed is that during the last couple of centuries, ethicists have slowly shifted over to the idea that exploitation of workers is morally wrong, and popular opinion has to some degree followed. But what Sage and Rue experienced are built in to the system and are the norm, not the exception. The question is how to change the norm.

    • Willowcrow Says:

      Sara, thanks for your insights! Do you have any ideas about how we might shift it? I listed a few at the end of this post, but I’m very interested in hearing others.

      • Sara G Says:

        A huge one would be to support, where possible, businesses that treat their employees well. As a former bookkeeper with more than 20 years’ experience working for small local companies, I’ve seen businesses that treated their employees well and were ethically run, some of which also had pro-environmental stances; businesses that were too marginal to pay the wages and benefits the owner wanted to pay, and where the owners themselves didn’t take any benefits (even medical insurance) or any more money than was necessary to cover their own very modest living expenses, in order to pay their employees a little bit better; and businesses where the owners didn’t give a darn about their employees, paid them bargain basement wages and kept them below the number of hours per week that would require paying benefits, and stripped every possible cent from the profit margin because their only “ethic” was to amass personal wealth.

        That perspective gave me the idea of patronizing as many small local businesses as possible that treat their employees well, and using that issue as one of my criteria in deciding where to shop. I also developed the habit of praising these businesses to other people, since word of mouth is crucial to the survival of most small businesses, especially in smaller towns. Of course that has to be done in a tactful way, and without revealing confidential information, so for example if asked to recommend a store I’d say “Oh, I always shop at so-and-so because Suzy treats people so well. She’s as nice to her employees as she is to her customers, and she really cares about running a green business. She’s just great, and I love to shop there.” Conversely, if I knew a shop owner didn’t treat their employees well, I’d flatly refuse to shop there, and if asked about the shop, instead of mentioning poor treatment of the employees (because it would involve revealing confidential information about the business), I’d say something like “I don’t like Erica’s shop. I prefer Suzy’s shop; it’s much nicer, and she cares so much about the community.” IME, change can be supported from the ground up that way.

        The real challenge occurs at the legal level. As you’ve seen with Michigan’s right to farm act, as well as in many other arenas, a legal battle won once isn’t won forever. We could put into place good solid laws that protect the worker and limit the rights of business owners, especially corporations — but actually enforcing those laws once passed, and keeping those laws undiluted over time, is almost impossible. Even a constitutional amendment can be overturned or repealed later; lesser laws are all the more vulnerable. So that presents a very knotty challenge indeed, and I don’t have any concrete suggestions for how to rise to imeet t.

  3. Sara G Says:

    Sorry, that comment was incomplete due to sloppy editing. The last line should read “Since meaningful work is not available to most people at this time, the question is how to change the norm.” If we can change the norm, that would better the lot of those who aren’t able to switch to meaningful work.

  4. Jess Tess Says:

    This inspires me to continue working towards my dreams of engaging in “meaningful work” on a full time basis one day. My goal is to reach a point by next year where I spend 1/3 of my time in completely alternative stuff that fulfills me in every way and spend no more than 2/3 in a “mainstream” but nonprofit position where at least I am helping others. Thank you!

  5. Sissy Says:

    I have been in situations similar to both of your friends (I have a college degree that is apparently useless) and am so privileged to now be a full time mom and artist. Unfortunately, my husbands work situation is less than desirable. After spending 12 years with the same company and working his way up to a salaried management position (which has it’s own problems= mandatory overtime without extra compensation) he was demoted twice in the past year for a 30 year old felony his employer knew about when they hired and then promoted him several times. Now he has been moved to a department where he can no longer make any difference and works a job with no future. We save what we can with the goal of buying an old camper and going gypsy. Life is too short to spend it in a meaningless job.

    • Willowcrow Says:

      Hi Sissy, thanks for your comment! I’m sorry to hear about your husband’s work situation. I agree about life being too short to spend at meaningless work–have you read the book Your Money or Your LIfe? Its one of my favorites to help me think about these perspectives.

  6. Meredith Says:

    What a great post! I absolutely love your articulation of the concept of meaningful work and feel that you’ve hit the nail right on the head there. I was nodding in agreement with everything right up until the last section about viable alternatives. At 29, I’ve been on both sides of the fence–first working horrible, stressful, emotionally and mentally abusive corporate jobs and then opting out to follow my dream of working full time on my family’s farm. I worked part-time on the farm for almost three years (on top of a full-time corporate job–your description of how you have no energy at the end of the day and it’s just so much easier to numb yourself really resonated with me because I’ve so been there) before going full time two and a half years ago, and I am coming to the end of my faith in the local foods movement and local economy. This is my sixth season at the largest producer-only farmers’ market in our region and I have come to accept that I cannot make a living farming.

    The support and value systems that existed pre-WWII no longer exist, and there is not enough local demand for sustainably grown foods, fibers, medicines, and plants. (Despite some of our local non-profits, advocacy, and government groups–none of whom have any actual farming experience–claiming that demand is high and the problem is that we need *more* small farmers.) I have the land, and the knowledge, and the skills to produce gorgeous, high-quality products and I’ve tried everything from produce to plants to herbs and herbal goods to wool goods, selling at different farmers’ markets, local retail stores, on the farm, and online, but the people aren’t buying. I don’t fault them, because they’re still blinded by and trapped in the modern hellscape we’ve created for ourselves. They don’t understand what they lack, or that they’re killing themselves slowly with convenience foods and prescription medications. But I can’t keep putting my energy and my life force out there without receiving an equal exchange, aka a living wage. Going to the market is starting to become almost as much of a hateful, hurtful experience for me as working a corporate job was. There are only so many unsold fresh-cut herbs and plants you end up being forced to compost before it starts eating at your soul in the same way.

    Returning to the corporate world is unacceptable to me, so I’m hoping to pursue a clinical herbalism certificate and be more of a full-time herbalist than a full-time farmer. And based on my experiences, I think the way to make my own alternative living is going to heavily feature the internet and decidedly non-local economy and customers. Part of me mourns for the vision of local service and economy that I once had, but reality has become too harsh for me to cling to it any longer.

    I offer my story only as a bit of perspective on the matter of what viable alternatives might actually be. I’m still trying to figure that out. I think in general, we have a long way to go before there are viable alternatives for the large number of people who have been ground down and hollowed out by our current definition of “work.” And I’m all too aware that devoting myself fully to herbalism will be just as challenging in terms of making a living, but I actually think there is somewhat more potential for success than trying to make it as a small, sustainable family farm.

    In any case, I really appreciate the time and energy you put into making this post and I’ve bookmarked it so I can revisit and reread it from time to time.

    • Willowcrow Says:

      Hi Meredeth,

      Thank you so much for your comments. I wonder about where you are in relation to me? Here, I do see farmers and other entrepreneurs doing really well because of the strong commitment to local foods in this area–sauerkraut, kombucha, microgreens, kale chips, bath and body products–a lot of products are out there, and people are working full time, and regional distribution is starting to happen in multiple channels. But these have been hard-won battles, and for every successful endeavor, there might be 10-20 more that we don’t see. I am really sad to hear about your work with the farm, and how people aren’t buying, especially at what is a reasonable living wage. This story is so sad to hear….I wish there was more we could do.

      I’m also studying herbalism–just finished my 2nd herbal intensive weekend. I would love to hear more about your plans, and how they work out for you!

      Thank you again for sharing!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s